Skip to main content

Human Testing Instinct

5 min read
Qa

Qa

Your intuition comes from pattern-matching against years of 'that was weird.' AI doesn't have that.

Human Testing Instinct

TL;DR

  • AI tests what you tell it to test. It doesn't get that "something feels off" feeling when a flow is clunky or confusing.
  • Human testers have pattern recognition from years of broken software. "I've seen this before" saves products.
  • Your gut is a feature. Use it. Document the patterns so you can prompt AI better—but don't outsource the instinct.

The best bugs are often found by someone who thought "hmm, that's weird" before any test failed. AI doesn't have that moment.

What Human Instinct Catches

  • UX friction. "This flow feels wrong." Users would bounce. No test asserts "feel." Humans do.
  • Ambiguity. "What happens if I do A and B in that order? The UI doesn't say." Domain knowledge + curiosity = found bug.
  • Inconsistency. "We say X here and Y there. Which is right?" AI might test both paths; it won't notice they contradict.
  • Context. "We're in healthcare. That error message would terrify a patient." AI doesn't know your industry.
  • Recurrence. "We've had this class of bug before—cache invalidation. Let me check." Pattern recognition from past incidents.

Why AI Misses

  • No intuition. AI executes. It doesn't wonder. "What if?" requires curiosity.
  • No user empathy. AI doesn't imagine a confused user. It follows scripted paths.
  • No domain memory. AI doesn't remember "last time we shipped something like this, it broke because of Y."
  • No taste. "This looks wrong" is aesthetic and experiential. AI has no opinion.

How to Leverage Your Instinct

1. Trust it. When something feels off, dig. Don't dismiss it because the automated suite passed.

2. Make it explicit. When you find a bug via instinct, write down the pattern. "I looked at X because I've seen similar failures when Y." Over time, you build a prompt library: "Also consider scenarios like [your patterns]."

3. Pair with AI. Use AI to exhaust obvious cases. Use yourself to probe the weird, the edge, the "what would a user do wrong?"

4. Advocate. When you sense risk, say so. "I don't have a repro yet, but this area feels under-tested." That's valuable even before you find a bug.

Manual process. Repetitive tasks. Limited scale.

Click "With AI" to see the difference →

Quick Check

What remains human when AI automates more of this role?

Do This Next

  1. Recall one bug you found by instinct, not by a script. Write down the pattern: what made you look? Add it to a "human testing checklist" for future features.
  2. Next time you think "that's weird," pause. Dig. Don't let it go. If it's nothing, you've lost 10 minutes. If it's a bug, you've saved the release.